Lucid Brands Home
©Lucid Brands 2026
Website SEO resource article: SEO Competitor Analysis: Step by Step

SEO Competitor Analysis: Step by Step

An SEO competitor analysis is a structured review of the websites that outrank you in search, to learn which keywords, content, links and technical strengths put them there. You identify your real search competitors, compare keyword rankings, content, backlinks, site health and AI search visibility, then turn the gaps into a prioritized plan. Most small businesses can run a useful version in a day with free tools and repeat it every quarter.

What is an SEO competitor analysis?

It answers three questions:

  1. Who competes with you in search results (not just in your market)?
  2. Why do they rank: which pages, keywords, links and site qualities?
  3. What should you do first to close the gap?

It is narrower than a business competitive analysis, which also covers pricing, offers and positioning.

Position matters. Siteimprove reports that about two thirds of clicks go to the first five organic results, so moving from position eight to four can change traffic far more than moving from 25 to 15.

When to run one

  • Before starting SEO or building a new site.
  • When rankings or traffic drop.
  • When a new competitor appears in your results.
  • Before planning next quarter's content.
  • Every quarter as a routine check.

Step 1: Find your real search competitors

Your search competitors may not be your business competitors. Directories, publishers and national brands often take the top spots.

  1. List your five to ten most important keywords (services plus location, or main product categories).
  2. Search each in a private browser window.
  3. Record every domain in the top ten.
  4. Count how often each appears. The domains that show up most are your search competitors.
  5. Split them into direct competitors (businesses like you) and others (directories, publishers). Focus the analysis on the direct ones, but note the others because you may be able to get listed on them.

Time: about one hour.

Step 2: Compare overall visibility

For each of your top three to five competitors, note:

MetricWhere to find it
Estimated organic trafficAn SEO tool's domain overview
Number of ranking keywordsSame
Authority scoreSame (for example a domain authority style score)
Referring domainsA backlink tool
Number of indexed pagesA site: search in Google

Tool estimates are rough, so use them to compare, not as exact numbers.

Step 3: Find keyword gaps

A keyword gap is a search term competitors rank for and you do not.

  • With a paid tool: run a keyword gap report with your domain and up to four competitors.
  • Free method: search your main services and their variations (cost, near me, best, how to) and note where competitors appear and you do not. Use Google Search Console to see where you already rank on page two.

Sort gaps into three groups: quick wins (you rank 11 to 20), new pages needed, and terms not worth chasing. See keyword research.

Time: two to three hours.

Step 4: Analyze competitor content

Open the competitor pages that rank for your target terms and record:

  • Page type (service page, guide, list, tool).
  • Headings and subtopics covered.
  • Depth. Siteimprove reports page one results average 1,447 words, but match the depth of what actually ranks for each query rather than a fixed count.
  • Media: images, video, tables, calculators.
  • Freshness: last updated date.
  • Signs of expertise: author, credentials, reviews, original photos.

Then ask: what could we publish that is clearly better or different?

Links remain a strong ranking signal. Siteimprove notes that 66% of web pages have no backlinks at all, so even a few good links can set you apart.

  • Find which sites link to competitors but not to you.
  • Look for patterns: local news, chambers of commerce, suppliers, sponsorships, directories, guest articles.
  • Note which competitor pages attract the most links and why.

Read our guide to backlinks.

Step 6: Check technical health

Compare page speed, mobile usability, HTTPS, indexing problems, site structure, internal linking and structured data. Run the same checks on your own site with an SEO audit. Our technical SEO guide explains each item.

Step 7: Check AI search visibility

Search engines and AI assistants now answer many queries directly. Check:

  • Which competitors are cited in Google AI Overviews for your key terms.
  • What ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity say when asked for the best provider of your service in your area.
  • Which sources those answers cite (reviews, directories, competitor pages).

Note what the cited pages have in common: clear answers, structured data, reviews, consistent business details. Our AI SEO guide covers how to improve.

Step 8: Score competitors and build the plan

Score each competitor from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong) and do the same for yourself.

AreaYouCompetitor ACompetitor BCompetitor C
Keyword coverage
Content quality and depth
Backlinks
Technical health
Local signals (reviews, profile)
AI search visibility
Total

Your biggest gaps against the strongest competitor become the plan. Rank actions by impact and effort, then pick three for the next 90 days.

Worked example

A generic plumbing company in a mid sized city checks ten keywords like "water heater repair [city]" and "emergency plumber [city]".

  • Competitors found: two local plumbers appear on eight of ten searches; a directory appears on six.
  • Keyword gap: competitor A has separate pages for tankless water heaters, sewer line repair and slab leaks. Our plumber has one "services" page.
  • Content: competitor A's pages include price ranges, photos and FAQs.
  • Links: competitor A has links from a local news story and two supplier sites.
  • AI visibility: an AI assistant names competitor A and cites its reviews.

Plan: build three service pages with price guidance and FAQs, ask two suppliers for listing links, run a review request program and fix the Google Business Profile categories.

Template

Copy these columns into a spreadsheet:

Competitor | Domain | Appears in how many of our keyword searches | Est. organic traffic | Ranking keywords | Referring domains | Top pages | Content strengths | Content gaps | Technical issues | Reviews and rating | Cited in AI answers (Y/N) | Score (1 to 5) | Actions for us

Choose tools to fill it with our SEO tools guide.

Local SEO competitor analysis

For businesses that serve a local area, add these checks:

CheckHow
Map pack presenceSearch your top services from several spots in your area (or use a local rank grid tool) and note who appears in the top three
Google Business ProfileCompare primary and secondary categories, services listed, photos, posts and Q and A
ReviewsCount, average rating, how recent they are and whether owners reply
CitationsCheck major directories and industry sites for consistent name, address and phone
Location pagesDoes the competitor have pages for each city or neighborhood they serve?
Local linksChambers, local news, sponsorships, suppliers

In local search, review volume and recency and profile completeness often explain rankings faster than backlink totals do.

Time and effort at a glance

StepFree tools onlyWith a paid SEO tool
Find competitors1 hour30 minutes
Visibility comparison1 hour (rough)15 minutes
Keyword gaps3 hours45 minutes
Content review2 hours2 hours
Backlinks2 hours (limited data)45 minutes
Technical check1 hour30 minutes
AI visibility1 hour1 hour
Scoring and plan1 hour1 hour

These are rough estimates for a small business with three to five competitors. A large site or a national market takes longer.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Analyzing the wrong competitors. Use the domains that actually rank, not just the businesses you think of as rivals.
  • Copying instead of improving. Matching a competitor's page gives search engines no reason to prefer yours.
  • Chasing every gap. Focus on keywords tied to what you sell.
  • Trusting tool estimates as exact. Use them for comparison and direction.
  • Doing it once. Rankings change; repeat the analysis every quarter.
  • No action plan. An analysis without owners and dates is just a spreadsheet.

Turning findings into a 90 day plan

Sort every finding into this grid:

Low effortHigh effort
High impactDo first (for example, fix profile categories, add missing service pages you already have content for)Plan next (for example, a new pillar page and cluster, a link building campaign)
Low impactDo when convenientSkip for now

Then assign each action an owner and a due date:

ActionOwnerDueMeasure

Recheck the same keywords and competitors at the end of 90 days to see which gaps closed.

FAQ

How do you write a competitor analysis for SEO?

List your search competitors, compare their visibility, keywords, content, backlinks, technical health and AI search presence, score each area and finish with a short list of prioritized actions with owners and dates.

How often should I do an SEO competitor analysis?

Run a full analysis once or twice a year and a lighter check every quarter or when rankings change.

Can ChatGPT do SEO competitor analysis?

It can help summarize competitor pages, suggest content gaps and draft outlines, but it cannot see live rankings, traffic or backlink data on its own. Use real search results and SEO tools for the data, then use AI to speed up analysis.

Can I do SEO competitor analysis for free?

Yes. Private browser searches, Google Search Console, free tool trials and manual page reviews cover most of the process. Paid tools save time on keyword and backlink gaps.

See where you stand against competitors

Lucid Brands's free website audit checks your site's technical health and content against what ranks in your market. Our SEO and Content Management service starts at $500 a month and turns competitor gaps into pages, links and fixes. Contact us to get started.

Your path to lucidity

Get Started With a Free Website Audit

Not sure where to begin? Start with a free website audit. Our team analyzes your website's SEO, speed, content and user experience to identify what to improve first.